What Is a W-9? When You Need One and Backup Withholding
Written by Dane Janas, EA — Founder, Portside Tax & Accounting
Photo by Dallas Penner on Unsplash
In this article
- What Is a W-9 Form, and Who Needs to Fill One Out
- When You're Required to Collect a W-9 Before You Pay Someone
- How to Request, Verify, and Store a W-9 Step by Step
- Understanding Backup Withholding: Rates, Triggers, and Reporting
- B Notices Explained: CP2100/CP2100A and How to Respond
- Common W-9 and Backup Withholding Mistakes to Avoid
- Special Situations and What to Do Next
- Frequently asked questions
- How Portside can help
A W-9 is the IRS form you collect from a contractor or vendor before you pay them, and it is what certifies their taxpayer identification number (TIN) so you can report what you paid them correctly. If you skip it, you risk a mismatch with the IRS that can force you into backup withholding, which means holding back 24% of future payments and sending that money to the IRS instead of the payee. This guide covers what the form is, when to collect it, how backup withholding works, and what to do if you get a B notice.
This is general information, not advice for your situation.
What Is a W-9 Form, and Who Needs to Fill One Out
A W-9 is a short IRS form called Request for Taxpayer Identification Number and Certification. The current version is the March 2024 revision, which is still the one listed on IRS.gov (IRS: Forms, instructions and publications). The form itself does not go to the IRS. It stays in your files, and its whole job is to let you capture someone's legal name, business name if they have one, entity type, address, and taxpayer identification number, often a Social Security number or an employer identification number, along with their signed certification that the number is correct. That certification matters more than it looks. By signing, the person is also confirming they are not subject to backup withholding, which is a mandatory federal income tax withholding the IRS can require you to take out of certain payments in specific situations (IRS: Backup withholding "B" program). We will walk through when that withholding actually kicks in later in this guide, but the W-9 is the document that starts the conversation. Who should fill one out? Any independent contractor, freelancer, or sole proprietor you pay for services. Any unincorporated vendor, landlord, or attorney you do business with. Partnerships and most LLCs you pay, since their entity type on the form tells you how to treat them for reporting. Corporations are generally the exception, though there are enough carve-outs that it is worth confirming instead of assuming. If you are not sure whether a given payment will need a 1099 at year end, our guide on how to file Form 1099-NEC covers who gets one.
When You're Required to Collect a W-9 Before You Pay Someone
The trigger for collecting a W-9 is tied directly to whether you will eventually need to file a Form 1099 for that payee, so it helps to know the dollar threshold first. You generally need to file a Form 1099 once you pay a non-employee $2,000 or more over the year. That is a change from the $600 threshold that applied to payments made before 2026 (IRS: Am I required to file a Form 1099 or other information return?).
The catch is that you rarely know in January whether a contractor will cross that $2,000 mark by December. A project that starts small can grow, and a vendor you only expect to use once can turn into a repeat relationship. If you wait until you are close to the threshold to ask for a W-9, you may find yourself chasing someone down in late January who no longer answers emails, while you are stuck guessing at a tax ID number with a filing deadline bearing down on you.
That is why the practical rule is simple: collect the W-9 before you issue the first payment, not after you realize you owe a 1099. Treat it the same way you would treat setting up a new vendor file. Get the signed form, confirm the legal name and taxpayer identification number look reasonable, and keep it on hand, whether or not that vendor ends up crossing the threshold for the year.
This habit protects you two ways. It keeps you from scrambling to track someone down after the fact, and it gives you the documentation you need if the IRS ever questions whether you should have withheld tax on a payment. We cover how all of this feeds into year-end filing in our guide to Full-Service Payroll, which is worth a look if 1099 season has been more chaotic than it should be.
How to Request, Verify, and Store a W-9 Step by Step
Once you have decided someone is a contractor and not an employee, the next move is simple: hand them a Form W-9 and ask them to fill it out before you pay them anything. The IRS treats this as the natural first step after that classification decision, and it sets the record straight on who you are paying and how the IRS should treat that payment (IRS: Forms and associated taxes for independent contractors).
Requesting the form does not need to be complicated. Send a blank W-9 by email or through whatever intake process you use for new vendors, and ask that it come back before the first invoice gets paid. Make this a standing policy rather than a one-off request. If you wait until January, when everyone is scrambling to file 1099s, you will find yourself chasing people who have moved on, changed emails, or simply stopped responding.
Checking the information matters more than it looks like it should. Compare the name and taxpayer identification number against what shows up on invoices and checks. A mismatched name and number is one of the most common reasons a 1099 gets flagged later, so a quick look now saves you a notice down the road. Confirm the entity type the contractor checked, since that affects whether backup withholding or certain reporting exceptions apply.
Storing the form is the last step, and it is not optional. Keep the completed W-9 in your files for four years so you have it on hand if the worker or the IRS has questions later (IRS: Forms and associated taxes for independent contractors). A simple folder system, digital or paper, organized by year and vendor name, is usually enough. If managing this alongside payroll and contractor payments feels like more than you want to handle on your own, our payroll services can take that off your plate.
Understanding Backup Withholding: Rates, Triggers, and Reporting
Backup withholding is tax your business holds back from a payment and sends to the IRS instead of handing the full amount to the vendor or contractor. It exists so the IRS still collects tax on income even when the taxpayer has not properly certified their taxpayer identification number (TIN) or has not reported certain income in the past. Think of it as a mandatory deposit toward someone's tax bill, pulled at the source.
There are two main triggers, commonly grouped under what the IRS calls the B program and the C program. You hit the B program trigger covered elsewhere in this post when a payee's name and TIN do not match IRS records, or when the payee never gave you a completed W-9 at all. The C program works differently and applies mainly to banks, brokers, and other payers of interest and dividends. Under the C program, a payee can become subject to backup withholding if they open an interest or dividend account and fail to certify, under penalties of perjury, that they are not already subject to backup withholding (IRS: Backup withholding "C" program). The IRS does not jump straight to withholding on underreported interest or dividend income either. It mails four notices over a period of at least 120 days before withholding starts on those accounts, and withholding can also apply any time a correct TIN was not provided when required (IRS: Topic no. 307, Backup withholding). If the payee never fixes the problem, the IRS directs the bank or business paying the interest or dividends to start holding back 24 percent from future payments under the authority in IRC section 3406(a)(1)(C) (IRS: Backup withholding "C" program).
The current backup withholding rate is a flat 24 percent, which has been in place since the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act lowered it from 28 percent starting January 1, 2018 (IRS: IR-2018-205). If your business ever has to withhold under either program, you report and deposit those amounts on Form 945, Annual Return of Withheld Federal Income Tax, which is separate from your regular payroll tax filings (IRS: IR-2018-205). If you already run payroll through us, we can walk through how Form 945 fits alongside your other filings through our full-service payroll support.
B Notices Explained: CP2100/CP2100A and How to Respond
A CP2100 or CP2100A notice is a letter the IRS sends to a payer, meaning your business, when one or more of the 1099s you filed had a taxpayer identification number (TIN) that was missing or did not match IRS records. This is the "B" in backup withholding B program, and it is issued under Treasury Regulation 31.3406(d)-5 and IRC 3406(a)(1)(b) (IRS: Backup withholding "B" program). A CP2100 goes to larger filers, a CP2100A to smaller ones, but the response is the same either way.
First B Notice vs. Second B Notice
What you send back depends on whether this is the first time or the second time a payee shows up on one of these notices. For a First B Notice, you send the payee a copy of the notice along with a new Form W-9 and ask them to fill it out and return it. For a Second B Notice, meaning the same payee was listed a second time within a three year period, a new W-9 is not enough. Instead the payee needs to send you a copy of their Social Security card, or, if they operate under an EIN, an IRS Letter 147C confirming the name and number match. This heavier documentation requirement exists because the IRS wants proof straight from its own records or from the Social Security Administration, not just a self-certified form a second time around (IRS: Backup withholding "B" program).
Timing matters here. If you discover that a TIN is missing or is obviously wrong, whether through a B notice or on your own, you are required to start backup withholding right away on future payments to that payee, not after your next quarterly filing or at year end.
Waiting does not give you a grace period, the obligation kicks in as soon as you know (IRS: Backup withholding "B" program).
If a B notice lands in your inbox and you are not sure which version it is or what documentation to chase down, our Full-Service Payroll team can walk through it with you and help you get the paperwork squared away before it snowballs into a second notice.
Common W-9 and Backup Withholding Mistakes to Avoid
The most common mistake we see is treating backup withholding as a one-time penalty instead of an ongoing status. Once a payee is subject to backup withholding, it does not stop on its own just because some time has passed or you feel bad about it. The payee has to actually correct whatever triggered it in the first place, whether that was a missing or wrong taxpayer identification number (TIN) or an unresolved notice from the IRS. Until that correction happens, you are required to keep withholding at the 24% rate on future payments (IRS: Topic no. 307, Backup withholding).
Another mistake shows up on the payee side, with partnerships and S corporations. If your business operates as one of these entities and a client has been withholding on your payments, the entity itself cannot claim that withholding back as a credit on its own return. The credit belongs to the individual partners or shareholders, who each claim their share on their personal returns based on their percentage of ownership (IRS: Topic no. 307, Backup withholding). We see confusion here often, because business owners assume the credit flows wherever the withholding happened, rather than down to the people who report the income.
A related slip is forgetting to update your own internal paperwork once a correction is made. If a vendor sends you a corrected W-9, you need to update your records and stop withholding going forward, not just file it away. Small bookkeeping gaps like this are exactly the kind of thing that turns into a bigger cleanup project later, which is part of why we pair W-9 tracking with ongoing Accounting Services for clients who want one less thing to monitor.
Special Situations and What to Do Next
The W-9 process does not look exactly the same for every vendor or payee. A corporation generally checks an exempt payee code that a sole proprietor or single-member LLC does not, and a partnership or S corporation lists the entity's EIN rather than an owner's Social Security number. Those differences affect whether backup withholding can ever apply to a given payment, so it is worth confirming entity type before you assume a 1099 or a W-9 is not needed.
Whatever the entity type, the process starts the same way once you have classified someone as a contractor rather than an employee. You ask for a completed Form W-9 before the first payment goes out (IRS: Forms and associated taxes for independent contractors). Make sure you are using the current version. The March 2024 revision is the one listed on IRS.gov as of this writing (IRS: Forms, instructions and publications), and you should hold onto every form you collect for at least four years, no matter who the payee is.
If you are juggling W-9 requests, TIN checks, and year-end 1099 filing on top of running the business, that is exactly the kind of crunch we help small business owners through every January. Our Accounting Services cover W-9 collection and 1099 preparation whether or not we handle your bookkeeping day to day. Tell Portside more about your accounting needs and we will take it from there.
Frequently asked questions
What is a W-9 form used for?
A W-9, or Request for Taxpayer Identification Number and Certification, lets a business collect a worker's or vendor's legal name, entity type and taxpayer identification number before paying them. The form itself does not trigger any withholding, but the information on it determines whether backup withholding, a mandatory federal income tax withholding on certain reportable payments, ever applies (IRS: Backup withholding "B" program). The version currently in use is dated March 2024 (IRS: Forms, instructions and publications).
Who needs to fill out a W-9, and when should I request one from a contractor?
Anyone you classify as an independent contractor, freelancer or non-employee vendor should complete a W-9 before you send the first payment. Once you've determined someone is a contractor rather than an employee, the next step is to have them fill out Form W-9 so you have their taxpayer ID on file before money changes hands (IRS: Forms and associated taxes for independent contractors). Keep the completed form in your records for four years in case questions come up later.
What happens if a contractor refuses to give me a W-9?
If a contractor will not provide a W-9, you still have to pay them, but you cannot skip the tax piece. Once you know a taxpayer ID is missing or clearly wrong, you are required to start backup withholding on that payment right away, setting aside part of it for the IRS rather than waiting for a future payment cycle to fix the paperwork.
What's the difference between a First B Notice and a Second B Notice?
A First B Notice goes out the first time a payee shows up on an IRS CP2100 or CP2100A notice, and it comes with a blank W-9 for the payee to complete and return. A Second B Notice applies if the same payee is listed again within a three year window, and at that point a new W-9 will not fix the problem. Instead the payee has to send a copy of their Social Security card, or an IRS Letter 147C confirming their name and EIN match.
What is the current backup withholding rate, and how do I report it?
The backup withholding rate has been 24 percent since January 1, 2018, when it dropped from 28 percent under the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act (IRS: IR-2018-205, October 18, 2018). If you withhold under backup withholding rules, you report and deposit those amounts using Form 945, Annual Return of Withheld Federal Income Tax, a separate filing from your regular payroll tax returns.
How Portside can help
Collecting W-9s, tracking down missing ones, and sorting out backup withholding can eat up a surprising amount of time once you have more than a handful of contractors or vendors on the books. We handle this as part of our regular bookkeeping and accounting work, so the forms are in hand well before 1099 season instead of a scramble in January.
If you would rather have someone else manage the paperwork, from requesting W-9s to filing the 1099s that depend on them, our Accounting Services team can take that off your plate. Tell us a bit about your business and we will let you know what makes sense for your situation.
Additional Resources
For the most current tax information and regulations, visit the official IRS website or consult with a qualified tax professional like Portside.
The content on this blog is provided for general informational and educational purposes only. It is not tax, accounting, or legal advice, and it should not be relied upon as such. Tax and legal rules change often, vary by state and locality, and depend on your specific facts and circumstances, so the information here may not apply to your situation or may be out of date by the time you read it. Reading this article, or contacting Portside Tax & Accounting through this website, does not create a client relationship, an attorney-client relationship, or any other professional engagement. We do not provide legal services or practice law. A client relationship exists only after a written engagement agreement has been signed. Please consult a qualified tax professional or licensed attorney about your specific situation before making any decisions or taking action. Portside Tax + Accounting makes no guarantees about the accuracy, completeness, or timeliness of this content and is not responsible for any loss or penalty resulting from reliance on it. Links to third-party websites are provided for convenience and do not imply endorsement.
Need help with payroll?
Tell us about your team and how you pay them today, and Portside will follow up with a plan.
Tell Portside more about your payroll needsCurious how Portside can help you?
Let Portside help you navigate your financial challenges with personalized solutions tailored to your needs.
Learn More & Get Started